Ethernet-APL and Functional Safety – Why the Switch Does Not Need SIL Certification

When it comes to safety-critical applications, the question of certifications quickly arises. Especially in the context of SIL requirements, it is often expected that all involved components must also be certified accordingly. In Ethernet-APL environments, this frequently leads to the question of why Field Switches themselves do not have SIL certification.

The answer lies in their function.

A Field Switch does not process payload data in the actual sense. It does not read, interpret, or modify the data. Its sole task is to forward data packets. This principle is known as the “Black Channel” concept.

The actual safety logic resides elsewhere in the system: in the controller and in the field device. This is where safety-related information is generated, transmitted, and validated. Special protocols such as PROFIsafe ensure that data integrity is maintained at all times.

The transmission path itself — meaning the network including the Field Switch — intentionally remains neutral. It merely provides the infrastructure. As long as it is ensured that data arrives unchanged or that transmission errors are reliably detected, no additional safety assessment is required at this level. This means, for example, that the failure of a Field Switch must bring the system into a safe state — which is ensured as long as the defined safe state is “OFF.”

This concept offers a major advantage: it allows the same infrastructure to be used for both safety-related and non-safety-related applications. This reduces complexity and simplifies integration.

The seemingly missing SIL certification of the Field Switch is therefore not a weakness, but rather a consequence of the underlying safety concept. Anyone who understands this quickly realizes that safety does not lie within the transmission medium itself, but in the way data is generated and validated.

Write new comment

No comments found!

These articles might also interest you

Blog Explosionsschutz R. STAHL Ethernet APL Funktionale Sicherheit

Why Size Is Not a Disadvantage for Field Switches

Continue reading
Blog Explosion Protection R. STAHL Hydrogen Safety

Hydrogen – The Invisible Foundation of Our Lives

Continue reading
Blog Explosionsschutz R. STAHL Ethernet APL Funktionale Sicherheit

When the Field Switch Doesn’t Talk – Why PROFINET Communication Sometimes Fails

Continue reading